Michael Stewart blasts Rangers FC over VAR claims but breaks ranks on Celtic FC incident

Michael Stewart was left stunned by Rangers FC’ penalty appeals at Tynecastle, dismissing the incident as “embarrassing” while also weighing in on a separate VAR controversy involving Celtic FC.

The flashpoint came when Gers winger Djeidi Gassama went down in the box after colliding with Jamie McCart as he chased a cross from Thelo Aasgaard. Referee John Beaton waved away the appeals, with Heart of Midlothian FC going on to secure a crucial 2-1 win.

Discussing the moment on Premier Sports, Stewart strongly rejected claims it should have been a penalty, arguing Gassama was instead fortunate to avoid a booking. He insisted the winger had gone to ground too easily, labelling the appeals exaggerated and unconvincing.

Former Rangers defender Alan Hutton offered a more measured view, suggesting there was contact but describing it as a natural coming together at speed rather than a clear foul. Presenter Darrell Currie also noted that while the incident didn’t look like a penalty, it was difficult to definitively judge it as simulation.

Despite the debate, Stewart doubled down, maintaining that the incident was closer to a yellow card for simulation than a spot-kick.

However, the pundit took a more balanced stance on a separate VAR decision involving Celtic. During their clash with Hibernian FC, a goal from Joe Newell stood despite suspicions of a potential handball in the build-up.

Stewart sided with VAR official Don Robertson, arguing that the replays were inconclusive. He suggested the ball appeared to brush Newell’s body around the “t-shirt line” area before deflecting downwards, meaning there was not enough clear evidence to overturn the on-field decision.

While acknowledging that opinions may differ, Stewart stressed the importance of consistency, insisting that marginal calls without definitive proof should not lead to goals being disallowed.

The contrasting views once again highlight the ongoing debate around VAR in Scottish football, with Stewart’s outspoken reactions ensuring the controversy remains firmly in the spotlight.