Celtic
Willie Collum backs referee over controversial Celtic VAR incident
Willie Collum explains why Celtic defender Colby Donovan escaped red card against Dundee United
Celtic defender Colby Donovan was correctly shown a yellow card for his challenge during the 2-2 draw with Dundee United, according to Scottish refereeing chief Willie Collum.
The incident occurred during the teams’ meeting at Celtic Park on October 28, shortly after Dundee United had moved ahead 2-1.

Donovan challenged United forward Zac Sapsford, making contact with the opponent’s leg despite getting to the ball first. Dundee United players immediately appealed for a red card, but referee Steven McLean decided that a booking was the appropriate punishment.
VAR official Chris Graham reviewed the incident but saw no reason to recommend an on-field review.
The decision generated considerable debate, particularly because of the height of Donovan’s challenge. However, Collum has now explained why the officials believed the incident did not meet the threshold for a sending-off.
Willie Collum backs referee over Colby Donovan challenge
Speaking during the latest VAR Review programme, Collum highlighted Donovan’s attempt to pull his leg away during the collision.
He explained that the defender did not continue driving his leg into Sapsford after making contact. That movement was an important consideration when assessing whether the challenge involved excessive force or brutality.
Collum also praised the communication between the referee and VAR team, explaining that their assessment of the incident was consistent with what McLean had witnessed on the pitch.
Although the height of the contact could have been considered when examining a possible red card, Collum stressed that officials must evaluate the complete challenge rather than focus on one aspect in isolation.
His position was that the incident did not satisfy all the necessary conditions for VAR intervention, meaning the original yellow-card decision should stand.
Pundits divided over Celtic’s Colby Donovan decision
Donovan’s challenge attracted further attention because it came shortly after St Johnstone winger Kai Fotheringham had been dismissed for a similar incident against Rangers.
Former Celtic midfielder Scott Allan was among those who questioned why Donovan remained on the pitch.
Allan believed there were similarities between the two challenges, particularly regarding the contact made with the opponent’s leg.
However, he also acknowledged that Donovan’s challenge appeared to involve less momentum and a different level of contact.
The comparison raised questions about consistency in Scottish refereeing, with Dundee United supporters among those likely to have wanted a red card.
Collum’s explanation has now provided the refereeing department’s position on the controversial moment, with the officials maintaining that McLean’s decision to issue a yellow card was correct.
Celtic2 months agoMcInnes reveals what sparked fiery touchline spat with Mark Fotheringham
Rangers2 months agoHow Uefa Decision made Rangers Humiliation worse.
Rangers2 months agoRangers star Bojan Miovski handed reality check after latest North Macedonia outing
Rangers2 months agoTom English reacts to ‘dismal’ Rangers news as Ibrox concern emerges
EFL2 months agoEFL respond to Millwall request over David Sullivan ahead of West Ham clash
Rangers2 months agoOli McBurnie may be feeling the heat as Scotland fans turn their Rangers frustration on him
Celtic2 months agoDerek McInnes involved in heated Celtic-Rangers exchange with John Fotheringham
Celtic2 months agoCeltic have already found McGregor replacement as Scott Brown backs star








